| Season | Coach | Record | Notes |
| Overall, Conference | |||
| Independent | |||
| 1967 | Mary Littlewood | 5-1, - | |
| 1968 | No Records | ||
| 1969 | No Records | ||
| 1970 | Mary Littlewood | 10-2, - | |
| 1971 | Mary Littlewood | 12-3, - | DGWS WCWS |
| 1972 | Mary Littlewood | 13-2, - | DGWS WCWS Champs |
| 1973 | Mary Littlewood | 13-2, - | AIAW WCWS Champs |
| 1974 | Mary Littlewood | 8-4, - | |
| Intermountain Conference | |||
| 1975 | Mary Littlewood | 15-3, 9-2 | Regional |
| 1976 | Mary Littlewood | 22-7, 13-4 | AIAW WCWS |
| 1977 | Mary Littlewood | 26-7, 13-1 | AIAW WCWS |
| 1978 | Mary Littlewood | 29-5, 13-3 | AIAW WCWS |
| 1979 | Mary Littlewood | 28-7, 10-0 | AIAW WCWS |
| Western Collegiate Athletic Association | |||
| 1980 | Mary Littlewood | 33-11, 15-3 | Regional |
| 1981 | Mary Littlewood | 35-17, 6-6 | Regional |
| 1982 | Mary Littlewood | 34-18, 11-9 | NCAA WCWS |
| 1983 | Mary Littlewood | 22-19-1, 9-12-1 | |
| 1984 | Mary Littlewood | 33-15, 6-4 | NCAA Regional |
| 1985 | Mary Littlewood | 38-17, 6-6 | NCAA Regional |
| Pac-12 Conference | |||
| 1986 | Mary Littlewood | 32-17, 7-4 | NCAA Regional |
| 1987 | Mary Littlewood | 41-15, 6-4 | NCAA WCWS |
| 1988 | Mary Littlewood | 26-25, 8-12 | |
| 1989 | Mary Littlewood | 34-26, 7-13 | NCAA Regional |
| 1990 | Linda Wells | 43-32, 10-10 | NCAA Regional |
| 1991 | Linda Wells | 43-18, 15-5 | NCAA Regional |
| 1992 | Linda Wells | 27-21, 7-9 | |
| 1993 | Linda Wells | 34-26, 13-11 | NCAA Regional |
| 1994 | Linda Wells | 22-41, 7-17 | |
| 1995 | Linda Wells | 29-26, 10-18 | |
| 1996 | Linda Wells | 34-27, 10-18 | |
| 1997 | Linda Wells | 32-25, 9-19 | NCAA Regional |
| 1998 | Linda Wells | 38-27, 9-19 | NCAA Regional |
| 1999 | Linda Wells | 41-28, 8-20 | NCAA WCWS |
| 2000 | Linda Wells | 43-20, 8-13 | NCAA Regional |
| 2001 | Linda Wells | 36-22, 9-12 | NCAA Regional |
| 2002 | Linda Wells | 46-20, 10-11 | NCAA WCWS |
| 2003 | Linda Wells | 32-25, 7-14 | NCAA Regional |
| 2004 | Linda Wells | 33-31, 3-17 | |
| 2005 | Linda Wells | 30-26, 4-17 | NCAA Regional |
| 2006 | Clint Myers | 53-15, 11-10 | NCAA WCWS |
| 2007 | Clint Myers | 54-17, 13-8 | NCAA WCWS |
| 2008 | Clint Myers | 66-5, 18-3 |
Pac-10 Champions, NCAA WCWS Champions |
| 2009 | Clint Myers | 47-19, 10-11 | NCAA WCWS |
| 2010 | Clint Myers | 44-17, 10-11 | NCAA Super Regional |
| 2011 | Clint Myers | 60-6, 17-4 |
Pac-10 Champions, NCAA WCWS Champions |
| 2012 | Clint Myers | 53-11, 18-4 | NCAA WCWS |
| 2013 | Clint Myers | 50-12, 16-8 | NCAA WCWS |
| 2014 | Craig Nicholson | 46-12-1, 15-7-1 | NCAA Regional |
| 2015 | Craig Nicholson | 36-22, 12-11 | NCAA Regional |
| 2016 | Robert Wagner, Letty Olivarez | 32-26, 6-17 | NCAA Regional |
| 2017 | Trisha Ford | 31-22, 9-15 | NCAA Regional |
| 2018 | Trisha Ford | 48-13, 16-8 | NCAA WCWS |
| 2019 | Trisha Ford | 35-20, 13-11 | NCAA Regional |
| 2020 | Trisha Ford | 22-7 | Season halted on March 12th due to COVID-19 Pandemic. |
| 2021 | Trisha Ford | 33-16, 12-9 | NCAA Regional |
| 2022 | Trisha Ford | 43-11, 20-4 |
Pac-12 Champions, NCAA Super Regional |
| 2023 | Megan Bartlett | 22-26, 6-18 | |
| 2024 | Megan Bartlett | 20-31, 3-21 | |
| Big 12 Conference | |||
| 2025 | Megan Bartlett | 35-21, 14-10 | NCAA Regional |
The official athletics site of Arizona State University Opens in a new window